Sign up
Log in
Results
View all 38 pictures
Size: 2.57 Acres
Type: House
Home: 2 beds - 1 full bath - 960 Sq Ft

2 houses on 1 property!

This beautifully maintained property offers two homes on landscaped acreage bordering Forest Service land. The main log home features modern updates, while the guest apartment provides income potential. With multiple garages, serene views, and abundant wildlife, this retreat combines comfort, convenience, and natural beauty close to town.

Highlights

Two updated homes offering living and rental income on one scenic property
Borders Forest Service land for unmatched privacy and recreation
Modern kitchens, luxury flooring, and multiple garages for convenience
Minutes from Custer with abundant wildlife and beautiful natural scenery

Description

NEW LISTING IT’S TIME TO COME HOME... x2! Two houses on one property! Enjoy carefree main-level living in this charming log home with a fenced yard, plus a separate apartment above the garage on a beautifully landscaped 2.5 acres bordering hundreds of acres of Forest Service land perfect for endless hiking, riding, and exploring. Features include new luxury vinyl flooring throughout and a like-new kitchen with brand-new hickory cabinets and stainless steel appliances. The spacious living room serves as the heart of the home, complete with a stone-encased corner propane fireplace, pellet stove, and a walkout to a covered patio that spans the length of the house. The main home offers two bedrooms, one bathroom, and a convenient laundry area.

An additional two-story structure includes living quarters upstairs and a tuck-under two-stall garage below with cove heating and a wood-burning stove. The guest apartment is open-concept with a vaulted ceiling, well-appointed kitchen, cozy living room with deck access, and a comfortable bedroom and bath featuring a tile shower and heated jacuzzi tub.

Enjoy the countless benefits of living in the Hills while earning passive rental income next door. The property also includes a separate 20x26 two-stall garage/shop with an attached carport for added storage. Custom dog gates, a new metal roof (2016), and abundant wildlife including deer, elk, and turkeys add to the appeal. Recently planted trees, including a weeping willow, along with rock outcroppings, aspens, and pines, create a stunning natural backdrop. Just a 10-minute drive to Custer and all its amenities the best of the Hills is right outside your back door!

Read More

From elevation to risk assessment

Search for detailed parcel information including; Elevation & Vegetation Maps, Ownership Information, Detailed Parcel Information, Crop History Map, Soil Survey Productivity Data, and more.

Research Parcel Information

Directions

From Hwy 385, head west on Medicine Mountain Rd, left onto Custer Limestone Rd, left onto Big Valley Trl, property immediately on your left.

Property Video

Resources

Links
Property Website
Contact Seller

Faith Lewis Realty

Visit Website
(605) 597-3450
License # 14675
Custer, SD
Premium Seller

About Faith Lewis

Hi there! Im Faith Lewisyour dedicated Black Hills real estate expert. A proud graduate of Hill City High School (Class of 83), I first earned my real estate license in the mid-1980s. Since then, Ive worn many hats in the real estate worldagent, buyer, seller, and investoracross multiple states. But my heart has always been right here in the beautiful Black Hills.Today, Im thrilled to be back doing what I truly love: helping buyers and sellers connect through one-of-a-kind properties. Whether youre looking for your dream home, a hunting cabin, land with views, or something totally unique, matching people to the perfect place is what I do best.Im especially passionate about showcasing distinctive properties and using creative, strategic marketing to reach just the right buyers. Im also expanding into the commercial space, learning everything I can and working hard to bring the same level of care and results to that market.My motto? If youre lucky enough to live in the Black Hills, youre lucky enough.Lets make your real estate journey a successful and memorable onegive me a call today!

About Faith Lewis Realty

Seller Resources

Faith Lewis

Faith Lewis Realty
i
By clicking the button, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Provided By

Faith Lewis Realty, (605) 597-3450
Source: MLS# 85987
Listing last updated: November 6, 2025 at 2:59 PM
Report this listing

More by Faith Lewis