Cibola County, NM Timberland Properties, Horse Properties for Sale

Flying Wapiti Ranch spans 3,014 deeded acres in the heart of New Mexico’s famed Game Management Unit 10, one of the premier hunting destinations in the West. Surrounded by Cibola National Forest, this rare inholding combines unmatched big game habita

MAP

$11,000,0003,014 acres

5 beds2 baths

1489 Forest Rd 50, Bluewater, NM, 87005, Cibola County

Butch Porter

M4 Ranch Group

VIDEOMAP

$3,800,0006,854 acres

3 beds1 baths

000 TBA, Quemado, NM, 87829, Cibola County

The A Lazy A Ranch is the best value mid-large size elk hunting ranch in NM at $936 per acre. 2025 Hunting season will have 5 Ranch only ES/Rifle bull tags. The ranch boasts +/-6,854 (including lease acres), and is located 30 minutes from Quemado, NM

VIDEOMAP

36 La Tinaja Trail, Pinehill, NM, 87321, Cibola County

Tinaja Ranch provides a peaceful and beautiful rural escape featuring a 3BR 2BA home complete with city utilities and great year-round access in NM Game Management Unit 12. The +/- 290 acre property is subdivided, making it an excellent investment/de

Lauren Fichtl

Hayden Outdoors

VIDEOMAP

$68,500,00097,825 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

The Atarque Ranch embodies all the characteristics of a large acreage, combination wildlife and livestock New Mexico ranch. The ranch offers a total of 109,308+/- acres, 97,825+/- deeded acres, and 11,483+/- acres of State leased land that is incredi

Jeff Buerger

Hall and Hall

MAP

$2,999,9992,698 acres

3 beds632 sqft

555 Mesa Ridge Road, Tinaja, NM, 87020, Cibola County

Galleta Ranch has been a family-owned and operated cattle ranch for over 80 years. The family has been operating a big game hunting program providing outfitted and guided hunts for Elk, Mule deer and Pronghorn. This ranch lies within Big Game Unit 12

On the market for the first time in 40 years! Tallahogan Ranch is a one-of-a-kind +/-305-acre property featuring a main house, guest house, and two traditional Navajo hogans. A rare year-round spring-fed pond attracts wildlife, while towering pondero

VIDEOMAP

$999,000305 acres

5 beds3 baths

221/223 Five Gate Road, Pinehill, NM, 87321, Cibola County

Chris Fichtl

Hayden Outdoors

Under Contract

$15,90010.3 acres

Deerfield Drive, Ramah, NM, 87321, Cibola County

This beautiful 10.31+/- acres is located in the rural Pine Meadows Subdivision, just south of El Morro National Monument, in Western New Mexico. The property consists of two adjacent lots and offers an opportunity to use as a recreational property or

This 311-acre property is timbered with a pinyon and juniper mix forest and lies in the heart of Game Management Unit 12 in Western New Mexico, which is known for its trophy elk hunting. Located in Fence Lake, New Mexico, this property offers recreat

MAP

$279,900312 acres

NM36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

This property is located within Game Management Unit 10 and is known for its trophy elk hunting. It is enrolled in the New Mexico Game and Fish’s elk landowner system (EPLUS) for private elk tags and qualifies as a small contributing ranch (SCR). Elk

MAP

$324,800406 acres

NM 53-Ice Caves Road, Lot#WP001, Ramah, NM, 87321, Cibola County

Agua Fria Retreat consists of 40.95+/- acres. Nestled among the tall pines of the Zuni Mountains, along the banks of the Agua Fria Creek, this property has it all: a 3,250 sq ft handcrafted and built home and many other features. It is built with sec

VIDEOMAP

$1,296,75041 acres

3 beds3 baths

41 Wild Iris Rd, Bluewater, NM, 87005, Cibola County

Robert Espinoza

Hayden Outdoors

VIDEO

$14,9755.08 acres

Ramah, NM, 87321, Cibola County

This is a gorgeous and secluded approximately 5.08 acre property in Cibola County, New Mexico along the continental divide. It is Unit 6 Lot 73 in the undeveloped Tierra Verde Ranchettes subdivision. Lot 73 is mostly beautiful meadow but has some nic

YourCheapLand.com

MAP

$224,20044.8 acres

000 Forest Road 157, Bluewater, NM, 87005, Cibola County

If you’re looking for the perfect spot to build your DREAM CABIN look no further! Elk Ridge Estates checks all the boxes, tall pines, and Chinkapin oaks are abundant throughout the Property. Priced to sell! 12 lots available to choose from: 21 acres

Butch Porter

M4 Ranch Group

MAP

$107,70021.5 acres

000 Forest Road 157, Bluewater, NM, 87005, Cibola County

Butch Porter

M4 Ranch Group

$544,000638 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

$475,000160 acres

738 Moreno Hill Road, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

$1,248,000620 acres

3 beds1 baths1,100 sqft

Hwy 36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

$28,50010.9 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

$309,00063.9 acres

271 Mujeres Circle, Fence Lake, NM, 87829, Cibola County

$26,50011.1 acres

NM-36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

$800,000100 acres

79 Long Horizon Road, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

$250,00040 acres

1 beds1 baths1,080 sqft

61 Native Drum Pass, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

$98,0001 acre

2 beds2 baths

2147 NM-36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Under Contract

$26,80010.7 acres

32 Triangle Drive, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

$199,0001 acre

3 beds2 baths1,858 sqft

2093 NM-36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County