Jefferson County, NY Hunting Land, Horse Properties for Sale with Recently Sold Properties

Discover this special blend of flora, fauna and fishing along the pristine waters of Butterfield Lake. This extraordinary property offers an rarely-offered retreat accessible only by boat, ensuring ultimate levels of privacy and tranquility experienc

MAP

$299,900148 acres

2 beds1 baths650 sqft

46446 Butterfield Lake, Redwood, NY, 13679, Jefferson County

Waterfront Property: New 5.01 acres with 155 feet of kayaking stream with waterway estuary bordering over 20,000 acres of State Forest only $44,900. Where can you find boatable waterfront for fishing, kayaking, canoeing - also adjoining a 20,412 acre

$44,9005.01 acres

Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Jefferson County

An estate-sized property awaits you near the shores of Lake Ontario and in close proximity to the Thousand Islands - St Lawrence Seaway. Opportunities abound for investors, developers, wildlife and hunting/fishing enthusiasts, or make this stunning p

MAP

$1,250,000435 acres

NYS Route 3, Lot#WP001, Henderson, NY, 13650, Jefferson County

Josh Buell

10 acre Waterfront Property with 317' of Canoe Stream bordering the vast 20,412 acre Jadwin State Forest $78,800. HAVE. IT. ALL. 10+ acres of big woods on usable waterways with great access, all bordering a vast State Forest! BIG WOODS forest setting

$78,80010 acres

Cherry Wood Drive (Private - Gated Road), Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Jefferson County

50 acres Hunting Land for Sale with Solar Powered Cabin, Worth, NY! Turn-Key Off-Grid Woodland Home/Cabin with Pond in the North Country! If you ever wanted total seclusion, away from the hectic lifestyle of everyday hustle and bustle then this will

Hunting Property in Jefferson County, New York

Sold May 23, 2022

$249,00050 acres

3 beds1 baths861 sqft

4006 Thompson Rd 1, Lorraine, NY, 13659, Jefferson County

Waterfront 5+ acres for fishing and boating bordering over 20,000 acres of State Forest $49,900. Amazing bargain. Own 187 feet of boatable waters along Blanchard Creek, ideal flat waterway system for canoeing and kayaking. Views of your mature woods,

$49,9005.01 acres

13331 Henry Road, Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Jefferson County

New 10-acre waterfront woodlands with 502 feet of Kayak River bordering 20,412 acre State Forest, only $89,800. WATERFRONT: Own over 500 of flat water paddle-boat stream and estuaries. Canoe and Kayak over 2000 feet of mini-river, brooks and waterway

$89,80010 acres

13331 Henry Road, Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Jefferson County

For those seeking a private retreat with room to live, work, and create, this 195.6-acre Jefferson County property near Hyde Lake offers an inspiring blend of recreation, agriculture, and opportunity. Surrounded by natural beauty and protected wetlan

MAP

$469,900196 acres

3 beds1 baths1,472 sqft

39245 Hyde Lake Rd, Theresa, NY, 13691, Jefferson County

This large acreage property is perfect for anyone who desires a large property at an affordable price. The mostly wooded parcel boasts a mix of hard and soft woods, including aspen, soft maple, and a large grove of majestic pine trees that offer both

Sold

$259,900260 acres

2 beds1 baths

0 County Rt 41, Lot#WP001, Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Jefferson County

38 acres Hunting Land for Sale on Sandy Creek Gorge, Lorraine, NY! 4 Season Retreat with Building Sites for Cabin or Country Home! 38 acres along a year-round road just outside of Lorraine, NY, Jefferson County. With year-round access and three-phase

Sold Jun 1, 2022

$75,00038 acres

County Route 189, Lorraine, NY, 13605, Jefferson County

30 acres Land for Sale with Views of Sandy Creek Gorge, Lorraine, NY! Camp or Build an Off-Grid Cabin with Beautiful Clearing and Pond! 30 acres with a pond! Located on Sandy Creek Gorge in Lorraine, NY! Breathtaking views overlooking the Sandy Creek

Sold Sep 24, 2021

$75,90030 acres

Lorraine, NY, 13659, Jefferson County

Your home away from home awaits! This newly finished cabin is complete with well, septic, electric, security system, on a main road accessible all year round. Close to snowmobile, ATV, fishing and hunting. This cabin comes furnished with everything i

Sold Dec 10, 2021

$109,5000.4 acres

26944 Loomis Road, Lorraine, NY, 13659, Jefferson County

Marc Christmas

Christmas and Associates

Sold Aug 29, 2025

$44,90016.9 acres

County Road 15, Lot 1, La Fargeville, NY, 13656, Jefferson County

16 acre Building Lot for Sale in the Town of Orleans NY! Building Lot Just Outside of Town with Power Available! 16.92 Surveyed acres located in a 5 star location. LaFargeville, Clayton, Alexandria Bay, Theresa, and Redwood. This is LOT #1 and it off

Ethan Reynolds

NY Outdoor Realty, LLC

Sold Jul 3, 2025

$84,90060 acres

County Road 41, Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Jefferson County

60 acre Hunting Land for Sale with Power Available, Wilna, NY! In an ATV Friendly Area with 4 Season Access on Paved Rd! Located on a year-round, paved road, this property offers the opportunity for someone to build a home or cabin in the country wit

10 acres Land for Sale with 2,044 SqFt 4 Bedroom Home, Henderson, NY! Off-Grid Country Living with Solar System, Garage/Shop, and Trails! 10 acres along a quiet, year-round road less than 2 miles from Lake Ontario. Masterfully constructed with attent

Sold Nov 5, 2021

$395,00010 acres

4 beds2 baths2,044 sqft

8805 Lane Rd, Henderson, NY, 13650, Jefferson County

18.6 ACRES THERESA JEFFERSON COUNTY, NY Less than 20 minutes from the very popular summer resort areas of Clayton and Alexandria Bay. The property is being sold in as-is condition with an old shelter cabin. Great spot for a hunting cabin close to som

$25,90018.6 acres

30269 County Road 22, Theresa, NY, 13691, Jefferson County

David VandeWater

Vandewater & Associates

$29,9004.46 acres

County Rd 22, Theresa, NY, 13608, Jefferson County

4.46 acre Surveyed Recreational Land for Sale, Antwerp, NY! Open Fields and Wooded Hills Near Lake and State Forest! Located in the Town of Antwerp, Jefferson County. Welcome to Lot number 4. Beautiful multi-terrain property for sale with a perfect b

Ethan Reynolds

NY Outdoor Realty, LLC

Sold Sep 22, 2025

$25,9007 acres

County Road 15, La Fargeville, NY, 13656, Jefferson County

7 acre Building Lot for Sale in the Town of Orleans NY! Building Lot Just Outside of Town with Power Available! 7.01 Surveyed acres located in a 5 star location. LaFargeville, Clayton, Alexandria Bay, Theresa, and Redwood. This is LOT #4 and it offer

Ethan Reynolds

NY Outdoor Realty, LLC

Sold

$29,90010 acres

Lot 18 Berry DR, Lorraine, NY, 13605, Jefferson County

0 acres Secluded Land for Sale on Sandy Creek Gorge, Lorraine, NY! Tug Hill Wooded Family Getaway with Creek and Access to Snowmobile Trails! This 10 acres tract is ideal for family camping, building an off-grid camp, and experiencing the Tug Hill at

This 6-acre parcel provides the best of both worlds - lakefront for paddling and fishing and an accompanying parcel for hunting. Located on a county road with power nearby, this property features lakefront with a dock on Payne Lake - a 150-acre lake

Sold Jul 21, 2023

$99,9006.01 acres

Theresa, NY, 13691, Jefferson County

Marc Christmas

Christmas and Associates

Sold Jul 25, 2015

$59,9009.2 acres

2 beds1 baths1,050 sqft

5641 Bishop Road, Lorraine, NY, 13605, Jefferson County

Country home just 30 minutes from the Watertown Fort Drum area. Easy living in the quiet countryside with 9+ acres of rolling terrain make for a very picturesque setting. Bear Creek runs along the back of the property so grab your rod and head out fo

Dan Heisey

NY Land Quest

Sold

$64,90055.3 acres

Ridge Road, LOT#WP001, Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Jefferson County

Located off a well maintained county road, this property is accessible with ease. Hardwoods dominate the acreage and provide ample opportunities for harvesting deer, turkey, bear and small game. Walking the property provided the chance to see multipl

Josh Buell

50 acres Hunting Land with Solar Powered Cabin and Pond for sale in the Tug Hill! Turn-Key Woodland Home/Cabin in the North Country! If you ever wanted total seclusion, away from the hectic lifestyle of everyday hustle and bustle then this will be yo

Sold Nov 27, 2020

$249,90049.9 acres

3 beds1 baths864 sqft

4008 Thompson Rd 1, Lorraine, NY, 13659, Jefferson County

Waterfront Raised Ranch Home in Jefferson County! 106 acres land for sale on Indian River with mixed woodlands, hayfields, and trails throughout! Great opportunity for living the outdoor life in Redwood, NY! Secluded 960 square foot country home with

Sold Nov 5, 2020

$175,900106 acres

2 beds2 baths960 sqft

33950 Hanson Bridge Road, Redwood, NY, 13679, Jefferson County