Shelter Island, NY

Enter a City, County, State, or ID

3 Listings

Shelter Island, NY Lakefront Properties for Sale

- 1-3 of 3 Listings

Lakefront Property for sale in Suffolk County, New York

$5,150,0002.94 acres

5 beds4 baths3,206 sqft

5 North Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964, Suffolk County

$3,995,0001.74 acres

3 beds2 baths1,800 sqft

47B S Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964, Suffolk County

$1,095,0000.64 acres

12 Hilo Dr, Shelter Island, NY, 11964, Suffolk County

Similar Properties

Lakefront Property for sale in Lewis County, New York

$99,9005.01 acres

Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Lewis County

Imagine waking up to the serene sounds of nature, with a private lake just steps from your door. This is your chance to own a beautiful 5-acre property with 138 feet of prime lake frontage on secluded Blanchard Lake for just $99,900.

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

$239,90010.4 acres

Diana Center, NY, 13648, Lewis County

BLANCHARD LAKE and CREEK, NY: New 10.36 acres with 508 feet lakefront, waterfalls, riverine gorge and 710 feet of canoeable Blanchard Creek. First time this 10+ acre waterfront property has been every offered for private purchase. You will not find a

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

Lakefront Property for sale in Franklin County, New York

$16,900,0001,313 acres

12 beds14 baths10,467 sqft

Duane, NY, 12953, Franklin County

Welcome to Partridge Park, a truly exceptional property located in the Adirondack Mountains. This remarkable estate boasts over 1,300 acres of pristine private forest and features more than 5,000 feet of frontage along the Deer River. Nestled within

Jonathan Gorgas

Merrill L. Thomas, Inc.

$3,500,0002,499 acres

Malone, NY, 12953, Franklin County

Adventure awaits on 2,500 acres in Duane, NY! This expansive private forest property is divided by 3.5 miles of the St. Regis River, offering serene frontage on both sides and featuring a stunning cascading waterfall. The southern 400 acres are untou

Sean Rogge

Howard Hanna

$89,9001.33 acres

Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Lewis County

BLANCHARD LAKE: "Have it all" - Brand new lake property, 1.331 acres with 243' lakefront on Blanchard Pond and extra wide 413' pave road front with electric and phone lines along road. This is it, has it all, LAKEFRONT, PAVED ROAD (year-round access,

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

Lakefront Property for sale in Westchester County, New York

$23,000,0001.38 acres

7 beds9 baths11,931 sqft

Larchmont, NY, 10538, Westchester County

One of Westchester’s most distinguished waterfront estates, Villa Cheri is a legacy property where architectural provenance meets modern luxury. Originally built in 1898 and exquisitely reimagined through a multi-year transformation completed just fo

LINDSAY ROTHMAN

Compass Greater NY LLC

Lakefront Property for sale in Hamilton County, New York

$915,00041 acres

5 beds5 baths5,442 sqft

Indian Lake, NY, 12842, Hamilton County

Located contiguous to New York State Lands on 2 sides, this gorgeous property has been surveyed to 41 acres. There is over 1700' of frontage along meandering Beaver Brook on the other boundary. Two structures improve the acreage; a year round home wi

Dawn Timm

Timm Associates Sotheby's International Realty-BML

Lakefront Property for sale in Madison County, New York

MAP

$679,0006.32 acres

1 beds384 sqft

Canastota, NY, 13032, Madison County

Pure heaven: small acreage directly on Oneida Lake, with spectacular views and luxurious private space for the new owner to spread out on this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. Located on the south eastern side of Oneida Lake, this amazing largely wood

Josh Buell

Whitetail Properties Real Estate

Lakefront Property for sale in Essex County, New York

MAP

$999,0002.65 acres

Crown Point, NY, 12928, Essex County

Adirondack-Style Log Home with Lake Champlain Frontage Crown Point, NYNestled along the scenic shores of Lake Champlain, this stunning log home on 2.65 acres perfectly combines rustic craftsmanship with modern comfort. With direct lake frontage and d

Chad Bruyette

Whitetail Properties Real Estate

Lakefront Property for sale in Onondaga County, New York

VIDEOMAP

$1,995,000156 acres

Fabius, NY, 13063, Onondaga County

Spectacular offering! The former Toggenburg Ski area is available again with over 150 acres of wonderfully designed trails and slopes. With the tranquil sunrise setting to the magical shadows and sunbeams as the sun sets to the west- this year-round

Allen Olmsted

Canaan Realty

Lakefront Property for sale in Fulton County, New York

MAP

$159,0007.73 acres

Northville, NY, 12134, Fulton County

Build your Adirondack getaway on this incredible lakefront property. The property lies on both sides of the road, with the lakefront portion on the south side of the road. The larger section of the property is on the north side of the road, where the

Michael Fudzinski

Whitetail Properties Real Estate

Lakefront Property for sale in Saint Lawrence County, New York

Under Contract

$79,80024.6 acres

Edwards, NY, 13635, Saint Lawrence County

BEAVER POND, New York: New 24 acres with waterfronts along BEAVER POND, formed by BEAVER BROOK and also waterfront along a second brook between the POND and eastern side line. Enjoy 3 nature water features PLUS additional unique topography featuring

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

Under Contract

$79,90024 acres

Edwards, NY, 13635, Saint Lawrence County

NATURAL POND, NY: New 24 acres on a natural beaver POND, about 1000 feet of waterfront including overlooking the center of the pond. Plus own additional waterfront on a second brook. Unique ownership opportunity for big acreage along a pond and with

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

Lakefront Property for sale in Allegany County, New York

$424,9000.19 acres

3 beds1 baths816 sqft

Rushford, NY, 14717, Allegany County

This gorgeous three-bedroom lakefront cottage is truly a gem located on Rushford Lake in Rushford NY. A gravel driveway welcomes you with plenty of space for parking for family and friends, along with a designated gravel pad next to the cottage and r

Girard Kelly

NY Land Quest

$149,9005.05 acres

Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Lewis County

Wilderness Lake Front Property: 153' on Lake, 5.05 acres, use 20,412 acre State Forest, just $149,900. Brand new lake property ideally located between Jadwin State Forest (20,000+ acres) and Adirondack State Forest (over 500,000 acres of regional sta

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

$119,9006.02 acres

Natural Bridge, NY, 13665, Lewis County

New 6.02 acre lake property with 220' paved road with new electric lines along lakefront building area. Subdividable one-time in the future. Enjoy 100 feet of pristine level lakefront, with table top shoreline cove and excellent views down the length

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

Under Contract

$299,9005.95 acres

Talcville, NY, 13635, Saint Lawrence County

CLEAR LAKE, NY: New 5 acre, 200' lakefront on CLEAR LAKE. Five acre lake parcel on Clear Lake, never been offered to individual lakefront buyers. Finally unlocked from decades and decades of corporate ownership. Unique situation to own a waterfront p

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

Under Contract

$299,9005.02 acres

Edwards, NY, 13635, Saint Lawrence County

CLEAR LAKE, NY: New 5 LAKE PROPERTY, 200 lakefront on CLEAR LAKE. Enjoy breathtaking lake views down the entire lake. Unique opportunity to own legacy grade lake property. Never offered to the retail lakefront public. Be the very first to build here.

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

Under Contract

$299,9005.01 acres

Edwards, NY, 13635, Saint Lawrence County

CLEAR LAKE, NY: Brand new 5 acre LAKE PROPERY with 200 lake front on CLEAR LAKE. For decades and decades Clear Lake was owned by just two corporations. These two companies owned the entire lake and approximately 2,000 acres of forest lands around the

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

Under Contract

$499,9005.01 acres

Harrisville, NY, 13648, Saint Lawrence County

5.01 acres, 133 feet on Adirondack Glacial Lake, old Boy Scout property, dock $499,900 firm. Limited time offer, scheduled for potential development. Enjoy amazing lake, easy building site and very nice lakefront. Discover Portaferry Lake a natural g

Bill Wilson

Land First, Inc.

Home - United States - New York - Southern New York - Suffolk County - Shelter Island - Lakefront Properties