Allegany County, NY Houses for Sale

Escape to the tranquility and privacy of 103+/- acres of unspoiled nature, where towering trees, serene ponds and abundant wildlife surround this charming custom log cabin retreat. Perfect for those who cherish the outdoors, this secluded oasis offer

MAP

$799,999103 acres

3 beds3 baths2,160 sqft

4607 Waugh Brook Rd, Scio, NY, 14880, Allegany County

This Amish farm consists of a house, barn, large shop and stream on 13 acres located in Wellsville NY, Allegany County. Set along a quiet paved road in southern Allegany County, this 13-acre property offers a peaceful country setting with a nice ble

$219,90013.2 acres

4 beds2,328 sqft

3829 Fords Brook Rd S, Wellsville, NY, 14895, Allegany County

4479 Carson Road, Angelica, NY, 14709, Allegany County

This 10.87 acre property is an Amish homestead with barns and a pasture and has great potential to be a hobby farm located in Allen NY, Allegany County. This 5-bedroom Amish home offers a functional layout with a covered porch and open views. The fir

If you've been dreaming of land, real land, with rolling hills, wooded trails, open pastures, and the kind of seclusion that only the countryside can offer, this is your chance. Welcome to your forever escape: a sprawling 483-acre property nestled in

Under Contract

$1,100,000483 acres

3 beds2 baths1,024 sqft

1972 Monegan Rd, Swain, NY, 14822, Allegany County

We are pleased to present a truly private and hidden gem cabin in the rolling hills of Bolivar, NY. This 1998-built cabin is located at the end of a private road, leading past a pond and pines to an open meadow approach leading to the 480 sq ft retre

MAP

$159,90025 acres

1 beds1 baths480 sqft

0 Jordan Hill Rd, Bolivar, NY, 14715, Allegany County

We are pleased to present a beautiful farm of 12 picturesque acres just outside the hamlet of Fillmore. This expansive and adaptable property at 11991 Route 19 offers the perfect blend of residential comfort and commercial potential. The spacious 3,2

MAP

$479,90012 acres

4 beds2 baths3,296 sqft

11991 State Route 19, Fillmore, NY, 14735, Allegany County

Whitetail properties is pleased to present a rare custom built HANDHEWN LOG HOUSE made with second growth Canadian white pine logs. Experience the true feeling of stepping back into the charm of days gone by.THE HOUSEOpen concept in its design, and i

Under Contract

$379,90095.3 acres

10493 Mink Hollow Road, LOT#WP001, Farmersville Station, NY, 14060, Allegany County

This beautifully maintained 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom farmhouse, built in 2001 is included with approximately 16+/- acres and provides a wonderful opportunity for country living. Enjoy beautiful country and valley views from every part of the property, o

MAP

$319,90016.3 acres

3 beds2 baths

10477 County Road 23, Fillmore, NY, 14735, Allegany County

This secluded log home sits on 86.8 acres and includes 2 garages and a stocked pond located in Scio NY, Allegany County. The scenic driveway winds through a forest of hardwoods and evergreens leading to the secluded log home tucked deep into nature.

$399,90086.8 acres

1 beds1 baths1,747 sqft

3656 Putt Brook Road, Scio, NY, 14880, Allegany County

1870 Farmhouse with Barn, Shop, Ponds, Tillable Fields, Woods, and Endless Country Potential. If you’ve been searching for a property where history meets opportunity, this partially renovated 1870 farmhouse delivers. With 4 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms

MAP

$498,00082 acres

4 beds1 baths2,168 sqft

281 County Route 32, Arkport, NY, 14807, Allegany County

This 2-story, 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home is located in the Village of Wellsville. Ideal for an investment or residential opportunity. A great opportunity to turn your investment into a home or rental for potential income. The water and septic are sup

MAP

$70,0000.17 acres

3 beds2 baths

39 Grover Street, Wellsville, NY, 14895, Allegany County

This beautiful three-bedroom home sits on 51.4 acres of peaceful, wooded land in Friendship NY, Allegany County. The property offers privacy, seclusion, and all the space you could ever want for outdoor recreation, hunting, or simply enjoying nature.

$298,90051.4 acres

3 beds1 baths2,184 sqft

5601 Pigtail Road, Friendship, NY, 14739, Allegany County

Dan Heisey

Welcome to 8722 State Route 417a cute, two-story colonial set on almost 16 acres just outside Little Genesee. With over 1,600 square feet, this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers the space and setting for a peaceful country lifestyle. It's been freshly up

Under Contract

$84,90015.9 acres

3 beds1 baths1,600 sqft

8722 State Route 417, Little Genesee, NY, 14754, Allegany County

Welcome to 3187 Wightman Road, a wonderful and expansive 92.5-acre property nestled in the hills of Wellsville, NY - perfect for those seeking complete privacy, natural beauty and an off-grid cabin. This hidden tract offers a mix of food plot locatio

MAP

$299,99995.2 acres

1 beds1 baths

VL Wightman Road Lot#WP001, Wellsville, NY, 14895, Allegany County

This country retreat consists of a cabin and a stocked pond on 19.1 acres located in Bolivar NY, Allegany County. Located in the back hills of Allegany County, this secluded getaway checks all the boxes of a great country retreat. The cabin has a spa

Under Contract

$109,90019.1 acres

1 beds1 baths500 sqft

936 California Hollow Road, Bolivar, NY, 14715, Allegany County

Travis Thurston

Located in the rolling hills of Allegany County, this opportunity to own approximately 100 acres of diverse land in the Town of Wirt provides a variety of potential for your desired use. This expansive property features a blend of open hay fields, th

Under Contract

$199,900101 acres

5 beds1 baths2,756 sqft

7739 Monihan Rd, Friendship, NY, 14739, Allegany County

This cabin sits on 4.10 acres and borders state land in West Almond NY, Allegany County. Step inside this newly remodeled two-bedroom cabin and experience its warm and inviting atmosphere. The open-concept layout features a spacious kitchen with ampl

$179,9004.1 acres

2 beds1 baths840 sqft

7523 Miller Road, West Almond, NY, 14804, Allegany County

MAP

5764 Rees Rd, Fillmore, NY, 14735, Allegany County

Tucked away at the end of a quiet, private dead-end road, this 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom farmhouse is accompanied by a barn, aluminum shed and a workshop. Set on a scenic parcel with rare frontage along the Genesee River, this unique property has the app

Tucked away on a private and hidden hilltop, this 2.9-acre retreat offers peace, seclusion, and the perfect country escape. Built in 1998, the cozy 900 sq. ft. cabin welcomes you with an open-concept design and soaring ceilings. A spacious loft overl

MAP

$119,9002.9 acres

1 beds1 baths900 sqft

9522 Morris Ave/Wolf Creek Rd, Cuba, NY, 14727, Allegany County

You turn onto quiet Glinderman Road, and the countryside opens up. The home sits high on a little over 24 acres of mostly open pasture, and the first thing you notice is the view. The covered back porch faces west, so evenings end with sky-wide sunse

Under Contract

$329,90024.4 acres

4 beds2 baths2,400 sqft

9285 Glinderman Rd, Fillmore, NY, 14735, Allegany County

Tucked down a peaceful, dead-end road just southwest of Bolivar, this nearly 15-acre wooded parcel is your private hemlock and evergreen sanctuary. With roughly 1,400ft of frontage on a quiet rural road, it feels like your own secret hideaway- yet yo

Under Contract

$294,90014.7 acres

2 beds2 baths1,464 sqft

7755 Willow Brook Rd, Little Genesee, NY, 14754, Allegany County

This gorgeous three-bedroom lakefront cottage is truly a gem located on Rushford Lake in Rushford NY. A gravel driveway welcomes you with plenty of space for parking for family and friends, along with a designated gravel pad next to the cottage and r

$424,9000.19 acres

3 beds1 baths816 sqft

8581 Sunset Drive, Rushford, NY, 14717, Allegany County

This property consists of a house with a barn and a workshop on 3 acres located in Hume NY, Allegany County. Beautifully remodeled and full of country charm, this spacious homestead is currently an Amish property. Featuring a limestone circular drive

$289,9003 acres

5 beds2 baths2,800 sqft

6341 County Road 4, Hume, NY, 14735, Allegany County